A few months ago, I received an assignment from an
individual who had just acquired his third business. His
first business was a retail store that was quite successful.
He operated it for three years and then sold it for a
profit. He took the proceeds from that sale and acquired a
rental business. He operated that business for a number of
years and even purchased the property it was on, which
included a number of other buildings that he leased out. He
eventually sold that business for a profit and proceeded to
invest the entire proceeds, into a plumbing contracting
business. With the first two businesses that he bought and
sold, he dealt with sellers and buyers who negotiated in
good faith and fair intent. In both cases, a common lawyer
was utilized to avoid increased expenses to either party (this
is something I am definitely against under any circumstances,
it is penny wise and dollar foolish). After closing, in the
first two cases, there were some discrepancies and disputes
but they were resolved, without much effort and to both
parties mutual satisfaction. The third acquisition, the
plumbing contractor turned into a complete nightmare. This
individual naively believed that he and the seller were
using a common lawyer, but it turned out that the lawyer was
representing only the seller and that meant that the buyer
did not have any legal representation whatsoever. The
agreements and documents were all drawn up to leverage the
seller’s interests and any safeguards that are normally in a
buy/sell agreement to protect the buyer were nonexistent.
Every time a new discrepancy or dispute arose the buyer
would say things such as; “it is not fair”, “that was not my
understanding” and “that is not what the agreements say”,
and I kept having to point out that it may not be fair, it
may not be what you understood but it is exactly what the
agreements say, and you signed them.
I cannot stress the
importance of good, independent legal representation when
acquiring a company. Just because you may have been
successful previously without legal council does not mean
that you will be successful every time. An analogy would be
that you have driven for twenty years without having an
accident hence you may as well cancel your car insurance.
Having a good lawyer is the same as having an insurance
policy, you hope that you will never need to fall back on
the safeguards placed in any of the agreements because of an
attorney’s efforts, however you will be very thankful that
they are there if you ever do need to utilize them.
When choosing a lawyer, do not forget the old adage that
you get what you pay for. If one lawyer charges you $100 an
hour but takes 10 hours to do the same thing as a lawyer who
charges $150 an hour but only takes 5 hours to do the same
amount of work, which way are you better off?
Lawyers are specialists, they all have their areas of
expertise, do not hire a real estate lawyer to provide legal
expertise on your business closing agreements and documents.
After all, you wouldn’t go to a podiatrist for heart surgery,
yet they are both qualified doctors!
There are other advantages to using a qualified lawyer:
· A lawyer can be the intermediary in a tough area of
negotiation. If you have to deal directly with the seller,
you may develop animosities towards one another during the
acquisition stage. If you then need to contract with the
seller for a period of time to transfer his inherent
knowledge of the business and/or to train you in its
operation the animosity developed during the negotiation
stage may make an on-going relationship very strained.
· Having your lawyer request the list of due diligence
material required places a buffer of what might be
considered pettiness.
If you are comfortable with doing the due diligence on
the business on your own that is quite acceptable. You may
still want to have your lawyer request the information on
your behalf.
· It is best to have your lawyer do title searches, to
confirm that there are no liens or chattels on the assets.
Your lawyer can also check for outstanding lawsuits. He can
also ensure that corporate, sales and withholding taxes have
been paid to current dates.
· The lawyer is the best individual to determine that the
articles of incorporation are valid, that any dba’s (doing
business as) and/or fictitious names are valid, that the
bylaws allow the business to operate and be sold in the
manner that is being negotiated and that the minute books
are up to date.
· You may want your lawyer to verify that the wording
within any contracts that the current business has with
vendors and/or customers allows them to be assigned or
transferred to new owners. Many contracts contain clauses
that do not allow the contracts to be transferred or
assigned without the consent of all parties.
If there are customer or vendor contracts that have to be
renegotiated, I highly recommend that you renegotiate them,
not your lawyer. You are the person who will have to deal
with the other party, now is the perfect time to introduce
yourself.
· Should your investment require a partnership agreement
then your lawyer is the best person to draft it. Your lawyer
will ensure that as many safeguards as possible are placed
within the agreement.
· When entering into the acquisition of a business it is
wise to determine what happens to the ownership of the
business should something happen to you. In other words, it
is time to update your will.
If you currently reside in a different State than the
State where the business is located or incorporated, it is
best to consult with a lawyer who is licensed to do business
in the State where the business is located. He can explain
how the laws of your State may vary from the laws of the
State the business is actually registered in.
Corporations can be registered in one State and do
business in another state. Your lawyer will verify all
jurisdictional issues as part of his due diligence process
on the corporate entity.
To reduce legal expenses you should make a list of
exactly what items that you want to discuss with your
attorney before you visit him in person. Lawyers charge by
the hour, the more efficient you are, the more efficient
your lawyer will be, the less time you will take and hence
the less money that you will spend. Read all documents sent
to you by your attorney, make sure that you understand what
all the documents say. Lawyers are not perfect and make
mistakes as well. Make changes and corrections in batches.
In other words, read all draft documents sent to you, make
all the corrections that you require and make a list of
items you don’t understand or feel are miss worded. Then
contact your attorney to discuss the changes and
corrections. Taking this route will save you time and money.
Always remember that a lawyer is there to give you legal
advise – not business advise. If you need business advise
then contract with a business consultant.